Journal of the Korean Wood Science and Technology
The Korean Society of Wood Science & Technology
Original Article

Evolution of the Hanji-making Technology, from Ancient Times to the Present

Oh-Kyu LEE1,https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4858-1727, Seokju KIM1, Hyung Won LEE1
1Forest Biomaterials Research Center, National Institute of Forest Science (NIFoS), Jinju 52817, Korea
Corresponding author: Oh-Kyu LEE (e-mail: okaylee@korea.kr)

Copyright 2023 The Korean Society of Wood Science & Technology. This is an Open-Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Received: Aug 22, 2023; Revised: Oct 05, 2023; Accepted: Nov 07, 2023

Published Online: Nov 25, 2023

ABSTRACT

This study has delved into the evolution of Hanji-manufacturing molds and techniques from ancient times to the present, aiming to uncover the current state of traditional Hanji-making techniques. In the absence of records on Hanji-making, various ancient documents, rare books, and documents during the Japanese occupation period, among other artifacts and relics, were analyzed in this study. It was discovered that a sudden significant transformation occurred in the Hanji field during the Japanese occupation period. Soda ash and caustic soda were commonly used for the pretreatment of White bark. Furthermore, a chemical bleaching powder was introduced for the pretreated White bark. Additionally, manual beating of the bark was replaced by mechanical beating methods. While these changes brought convenience to papermakers, they also resulted in a deterioration of Hanji quality. Furthermore, it was revealed that the term “Hanji” has been in use since at least 1908. Furthermore, this study clarified that Heulimtteugi is not the only traditional Hanji-making method in Korea. Instead, there existed Korea’s own traditional Gadoomtteugi method, at least up to the 1930s, before the Japanese-style Gadoomtteugi became common in Korea. Additionally, for the first time, this study raises the possibility of the adoption of mold-hanging techniques into Korea’s Heulimtteugi method from foreign sources.

Keywords: Hanji; manufacturing molds; technological changes; Gadoomtteugi; Heulimtteugi

1. INTRODUCTION

Recently, Korean traditional paper Hanji has garnered significant attention owing to its use in restoring dozens of world-class paper cultural heritage pieces in Italy and the Vatican. In particular, in 2018, the Italian Center for the Preservation and Restoration of Documentary Heritage (ICPAL) announced that it had restored Leonardo da Vinci’s “Codex on Bird Flight,” which is known to have been produced between 1503 and 1506, using Hanji (Lucilla, 2021). It is believed that the main reason Hanji was used in the restoration of these cultural heritage pieces is because of its durability, softness, and resistance to tearing (Poggi, 2016).

The term “Hanji” appeared in a newspaper “DaehanMaeilShinbo (大韓每日申報)” in 1908 (Bethell, 1908). During the Goryeo Kingdom, it was called “Goryeoji” in China and was reputed for its quality. Furthermore, the cultural flourishing during the Joseon Dynasty was achieved through the extensive use of Hanji, which served as the primary material for large-scale publications. However, there is limited information available in Korean records regarding the technological development or characteristics of Hanji manufacturing during ancient times. It was only recently that research on this topic picked up steam. Early Hanji studies were conducted on the relationship between the production and consumption of Hanji (Lee, 1958) and the paper industry during the Joseon Dynasty (Lee, 1962). It was not until the early 1990s that scientific research on materials used in Hanji began. Studies on Hanji material in the 1990s mainly focused on the mass industrialization of products such as wallpaper made from a blend of Broussonetia × Hanjiana (hereafter Daknamu) bast fiber and wood pulp. Additionally, efforts were made to produce Daknamu pulp by applying the wood pulping technology (Choi and Cho, 1996; Jo, 1995; Yoon et al., 1996, 1997). However, these studies fell short of fully capturing the production technology that embodies the unique characteristics of Hanji. It was not until the 2000s that research on Hanji gained momentum, and it can be broadly categorized into two main themes. The first theme revolves around the Hanji manufacturing process and the examination of its physical properties. The second theme delves into the quality analysis of Hanji and the contemporary status of Hanji usage through the analysis of ancient documents or relics. The former corresponds to the change in physical properties according to the raw materials of Hanji (Lee et al., 2021a, 2021b, 2012c), manufacturing process of Hanji (Cho et al., 2009; Seo et al., 2001; Yoon and Ra, 2013), comparative analysis of preservation characteristics (Ahn and Bae, 2018; Jeong et al., 2012, 2014a, 2014b; Kang and Yang, 2012; Park et al., 2009), analysis of natural dyeing characteristics (Chung, 1996; Jeon and Jin, 2000; Lee et al., 2015, 2016; Park and Yoon, 2009, 2010, 2011; Roh and Jo, 2022; Yoo et al., 2009; Yoon and Kim, 2002), and analysis of surface treatment characteristics (Hyun et al., 2005; Yoon, 2015). The latter is related to the Hanji and its industry in the Goreyo Kingdom (Park, 2010, 2011; Song, 2016) and Joseon Dynasty (Jeon, 2011; Kim, 2002; Lee, 1958, 1962; Park, 2012, 2017; Son, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2007), the situation of Hanji before and after the Japanese occupation period (1910–1945) (Park, 2019, 2023; Shinya, 1909; Song, 2008), and the rediscovery of Hanji (Roh et al., 2021a, 2021b, 2021c, 2021d, 2022a, 2022b, 2023). As described above, Hanji has gained an international reputation in recent years. However, the details regarding the evolution and changes in current Hanji manufacturing techniques are yet to be fully elucidated (Han and Lee, 2021a, 2021b; Han et al., 2021, 2022). Therefore, this study seeks to clarify the current development process of Hanji manufacturing techniques by analyzing manufacturing molds and processes and tracing their evolution since ancient times.

2. MATERIALS and METHODS

2.1. Data analysis

The Hanji manufacturing techniques and the related matters used during ancient times were analyzed using various types of historical records and artifacts.

The primary sources of data frequently employed in this study were various forms of literature. The historical changes in Hanji manufacturing were revealed by analyzing contents in the old literature related to Hanji. If necessary, the contents were supplemented by analyzing the relics simultaneously. In addition, the changes in Hanji manufacturing during the Japanese occupation period were investigated by searching articles published in various recording media.

2.2. Types of data

The study utilized various types of data sources, including both Korean and foreign ancient literature, records from the Korean Empire to the Japanese occupation period, modern literature, and photographs.

Korean literature studied included Goryeosa (高麗史), Annals of the Joseon Dynasty Chosunwangjo-sillok (朝鮮王朝實錄), Donggukyeojiseungram (東國輿地勝覽), Ohjuyeonmunjangjeonsango (五洲衍文長箋散稿), Gyeonggukdaejeon (經國大典), Sanlimkyeongjae (山林經濟), and Takjijunjeol (度支準折). Regarding foreign literature, the books of Dard Hunter, a world-renowned authority on paper; books of Seki Yoshikuni (関義城), a Japanese authority on paper; and the writings of Panjixing (潘吉星), a Chinese historian, were used for the analysis.

Records from the Korean Empire to the Japanese occupation period include the reports of the government industrial training center (官立工業傳習所報告), the official gazette of the Japanese Government-General of Joseon (朝鮮總督府官報), the related publications, and newspaper articles during the Japanese occupation period.

Modern literature analyzed in this study mainly includes papers published in academic journals.

3. RESULTS and DISCUSSION

3.1. Changes in the pretreatment process of Hanji making

The rough process of Hanji-making includes harvesting Daknamu shoots, steaming, preparation of Black bark, preparation of White bark, boiling White bark, beating or fiberization, mixing the ingredients in a vat, making paper, and drying. On the basis of the related literature, the outline of the process has not changed significantly from ancient times. However, it was found that the types of raw materials, raw material pretreatment methods, chemicals, paper manufacturing molds, and drying methods have changed according to the trend of the times. These changes in Hanji-making process progressed slowly over a long period of time, but abrupt changes occurred during the period of Japanese occupation.

3.1.1. Steaming Daknamu shoots: Dakmuji

Daknamu shoots are steamed to facilitate the easy peeling of its bark, which serves as the raw material of Hanji. This process is called Dakmuji in Korean. In ancient times, steam generation was achieved through a traditional method of heating stones and pouring water onto them within a specialized facility. One of the traditional techniques involved placing Daknamu shoots on top of the heated stones, covering them with soil, and then covering the pile with soil for the steaming. Another way involves using a facility having two spaces in the shape of a gourd, connected by a narrow passage in the middle. In one of the two gourd-shaped spaces, Daknamu shoots are piled up followed by covering them with soil after covering them with pine branches. In the other space, a stone pile is made and a fire is built under it to produce heat, and then covered with soil and poured with water to steam. When steam is generated, it permeates into the adjacent space through a narrow passage in the middle, steaming the Daknamu shoots. Fig. 1 shows a traditional Daknamu steaming facility of traditional Hanji making, recreated in the exhibition hall of the Demonstration Culture Village in Bongsu-myeon, Uiryeong-gun, Korea (Lee et al., 2021c).

wood-51-6-509-g1
Fig. 1. A traditional Daknamu steaming facility for traditional Hanji making, recreated in the exhibition hall located in the Demonstration Culture Village in Bongsu-myeon, Uiryeong-gun, Korea. (a) A room for a pile of Daknamu shoots, (b) a space for a stone pile and fire.
Download Original Figure

These traditional Dakmuji facilities were also documented during a paper manufacturing survey conducted in Chungcheong-do and Gyeongsang-do during the Japanese occupation period in 1912. The survey noted that the traditional Dakmuji was considered inefficient in terms of wood consumption and labor. As a result, the Japanese-style Dakmuji was introduced and adopted in Korea. In the Japanese-style Dakmuji, a bundle of Daknamu shoots is placed in a cauldron filled with water in an upright state; the protruding part is covered by turning over a long and large wooden barrel, and then the cauldron is heated. This method continued to be used in some regions of Korea until the 1980s (Park, 2023).

Recently, the ondol floor method has emerged as the most commonly used Dakmuji method in Korea. As shown in Fig. 2 (Lee et al., 2021c), in this method, piles of Daknamu shoots are placed on a plate, covered, and subjected to steam by setting them on fire within a fireplace.

wood-51-6-509-g2
Fig. 2. A modern Daknamu steaming facility using an ondol-type floor. (a) Pile of Daknamu shoots, (b) covered Daknamu pile, (c) fireplace.
Download Original Figure
3.1.2. Boiling and bleaching of White bark

The term “White bark of Daknamu” refers to the inner bark after removing the outer bark. The White bark is boiled in an alkaline solution to dissolve non-fibrous substances in it to facilitate fiberization during the beating process.

It is documented that, during the Joseon Dynasty, ash from oyster shells (Kim, 2015a) or wood ash (Kim, 2015b) was used as an alkaline source for the boiling process. Around the Japanese occupation period, at least before 1908, there was a considerable change in the materials used for boiling White bark, and soda ash (Na2CO3, sodium carbonate), also called “Jodal” (曹達), and caustic soda (NaOH, sodium hydroxide) were used as a substitute for a lye solution. Another change was the use of bleaching chemicals in the process (Park, 2019). The introduction of synthetic chemicals in papermaking in Korea may have been influenced by the embracing of the Western culture, but widespread adoption occurred through the “papermaking class” held for decades at paper manufacturing sites across the country. This dissemination policy was implemented under the Japanese Government-General of Joseon to promote Japanese-style papermaking technology. Owing to readily available chemicals, it relieved people of the hassle of obtaining or making ashes, but the quality of paper decreased. Even today, these chemicals are commonly used in Hanji manufacturing facilities across Korea.

Alternatively, the boiled White bark may undergo a bleaching process before fiberization. In the natural bleaching method, White bark taken out of a lye pot after boiling is washed in a stream and then placed under running water for a certain period of time and subsequently exposed to sunlight. However, around the time of the Japanese occupation, the use of bleaching powder, a chemical produced through the reaction of chlorine and lime, became commonplace. It was recognized that while chemicals offered convenience, they could have a detrimental impact on the quality of Hanji. Furthermore, the use of bleaching powder can adversely affect the quality of paper (Ichiro, 1918).

In particular, caustic soda and bleaching agents are chemicals that can decompose cellulose, which is the main component of Daknamu bark and can affect the durability of Hanji. Therefore, presently, traditional Hanji manufacturers do not use chemicals when making traditional Hanji but rather boil White bark with natural lye and bleach under the sunlight.

3.1.3. Beating

The White bark that has gone through washing and bleaching becomes fiber through beating. The traditional method involves placing the White bark on a wide and flat stone and beating it with a long wooden bat, a highly labor-intensive process. Such manual beating methods appear to have been common in Korea until the mid-1920s. The transition to mechanical beating started in the 1930s (Hunter, 1936). While mechanical beaters are more widespread today than in the past, the practice of creating and using mechanical mortar and pestle devices that replicate traditional beating principles still exists. In addition, the traditional beating method using a wooden bat is still used to make Hanji.

3.2. Changes in molds for Hanji-making

As there are almost no records or relics of Hanji-making molds that have been handed down from ancient times, the changes were analyzed by comparing them with the molds from Korea, China, and Japan, which have exchanged their papermaking technology since ancient times.

3.2.1. Primitive papermaking mold

It is not clear when the papermaking technology was first introduced in Korea. However, given geographical proximity, it can be safely assumed that the technology entered Korea shortly after paper was invented in China.

In the early days of papermaking, the primitive papermaking mold was typically prepared by tying four wooden sticks to form a square and securing it with a square-sized woven cloth, as shown in Fig. 3. In addition, willow or rattan was installed in a square frame in place of cloth. These papermaking molds, akin to the temporary container type known as “Gadoomtteugi” in Korean, were originally used in China.

wood-51-6-509-g3
Fig. 3. A primitive papermaking mold with woven cloth. Photo taken by the author in May 2022 at the Robert C. Williams Museum of Papermaking, Atlanta, USA.
Download Original Figure

A common method of papermaking involves extracting the fibrous material using a screen from a vat containing a mixture of fiberized raw materials, additives such as plant mucilage, and water. Meanwhile, in papermaking using the molds shown in Fig. 3, the sieve or mesh is submerged in water, and then a certain amount of mixture is poured onto the mesh or sieve so that the fibers are spread evenly over the entire surface. Subsequently, the mold is lifted to strain water and dry to make paper. The mold used in the early days of papermaking technology in Korea was likely similar to these primitive Chinese molds. The downside of this method is that each mold could produce only a single sheet of paper. Consequently, a large number of molds were needed to produce a substantial quantity of paper.

3.2.2. Advanced form of papermaking mold
3.2.2.1. Chinese papermaking mold

A more advanced form compared with the above primitive papermaking mold is using a mold composed of a screen, a supporting frame, and a deckle or deckle sticks (Fig. 4). A screen is treated as the mesh or sieve of the primitive type molds, and a supporting frame supports the screen. Papermaking is performed first by placing the screen on the supporting frame, then adding deckle sticks on top of the screen, and finally scooping the mixture from the vat. In this process, the mixture is temporarily contained in a room constituting the screen and deckle, and water spontaneously drains because the screen acts as a strainer; as a result, fibers are left on top of it. The wet sheet of fiber is separated from the screen for drying so that the screen can be used for the next batch immediately. That is, multiple sheets of paper can be continuously produced using just one set of molds, significantly enhancing production efficiency.

wood-51-6-509-g4
Fig. 4. An assembling scheme of papermaking mold composed of a screen, a supporting frame, and two deckle sticks.
Download Original Figure
3.2.2.2. Japanese papermaking mold

A papermaking mold using a frame deckle instead of deckle sticks, as shown in Fig. 5, was used in Japan. In this setup, the screen is placed on the supporting frame, and the frame deckle is placed on top of the screen. Paper is then made by scooping the vat while holding the frame deckle. As this method does not use cumbersome deckle sticks, the associated procedure is more convenient. However, in this case as well, it is not possible to completely preempt the difficulty involved in removing the frame deckle every time.

wood-51-6-509-g5
Fig. 5. An assembling scheme of papermaking mold composed of a supporting frame, a screen, and a frame deckle.
Download Original Figure

As a solution to the inconvenience of detaching the frame deckle every time, a more advanced mold was developed. This innovation involved connecting the frame deckle and the supporting frame with a hinge (Fig. 6). This hinge-fixed papermaking mold is still the most commonly used technique in Japan.

wood-51-6-509-g6
Fig. 6. An assembling scheme of hinge-fixed papermaking mold composed of a supporting frame, a screen, and a hinge-fixed deckle.
Download Original Figure
3.2.2.3. Korean papermaking mold

Two types of papermaking molds have been developed in Korea. One is Gadoomtteugi mold, which operates similarly to those used in China and Japan, as described earlier. The other one is the Heulimtteugi mold, which was developed only in Korea.

3.2.2.3.1. Heulimtteugi mold

Korea has developed a unique papermaking mold that is different from those of other countries, called the Heulimtteugi mold. This mold does not constitute deckle or deckle sticks. It is simply composed of a screen and a supporting frame (Fig. 7). The Heulimtteugi mold is the only type of mold that has been used in Korea for making traditional Hanji up to the present time.

wood-51-6-509-g7
Fig. 7. A Heulimtteugi mold composed of a supporting frame and a screen (a) and the assembling scheme of them (b).
Download Original Figure
3.2.2.3.2. Gadoomtteugi mold

A picture with a precise description of the old Korean-type Gadoomtteugi mold was found in Dard Hunter’s book titled “A PAPERMAKING PILGRIMAGE to Japan, Korea, and China,” published in 1936. This is a Hanji-making mold (Fig. 8) that Dard Hunter collected in 1933 from a papermaking village in Eunpyeong. According to the book, this mold consists of a screen with thick wooden ends attached to the left and right ends, a supporting frame, and two deckle sticks at the upper and lower ends. It also said that this mold was used for making flooring paper. When manufacturing Hanji using this mold, the two wooden ends mounted on the left and right sides of the screen and two deckle sticks at the top and bottom act as a deckle. The operation principle of the mold is similar to that used in the Chinese mold, as shown in Fig. 4, but the location and size of the two deckle sticks are different.

wood-51-6-509-g8
Fig. 8. The artifact of papermaking mold stored in the Robert C. Williams Museum of Papermaking in the U.S.: Two deckle sticks and the wooden ends of the screen wrapped with white cloth are observed (a) and a hand writing ‘KOREA 1933’ (b), displaying the collection country and year.
Download Original Figure

The mold shown in Fig. 8 is probably the only Korean traditional Gadoomtteugi mold that has been reported so far, with a detailed description of the structure and materials. To provide further clarity regarding the mold, an investigation on the artifact mentioned in Hunter’s book was carried out by the authors’ team at the Robert C. Williams Museum of Papermaking in the United States in 2022. The investigation confirmed that the wooden ends, which are wrapped with white cotton cloth, and the two deckle sticks can act as a deckle [Fig. 8(a)]. The picture on the Fig. 8(b) shows a handwritten inscription “KOREA 1933,” which was written in a flat cross-piece in the back, displaying the country of collection and year of the mold. Because there is a strong tendency to accept that Heulimtteugi is the only traditional papermaking technique in Korea, this confirmation of Gadoomtteugi’s historical presence becomes especially significant in establishing it as one of Korea’s traditional papermaking techniques.

However, the Korean traditional Gadoomtteugi mold and methods have not been handed down to the present age. This can be attributed to the widespread influence of the generalized Japanese-style Gadoomtteugi mold shown in Fig. 6, which was introduced and adopted in Korea during the Japanese occupation period, subsequently spreading throughout the country.

3.2.2.3.3. Raw materials and shapes of the screen for Hanji-making

There has been a shift in the material used for Hanji-making screens. Currently, the screens for Hanji-making commonly seen are thin, round bamboo strips, known as “laid,” which are interlaced using a fiber string or horse hair. Furthermore, historical records indicate that screens made from silver grass (Miscanthus spp.) were used for Hanji-making in Korea during the 1910s to 1930s (Hunter, 1936; Park, 2023). Thus, screens made of silver grass as well as bamboo strips were used to make Hanji in the ancient days, but it appears that the tradition of using a screen made of silver grass disappeared during the Japanese occupation period.

Relics and old photographs of the screens for papermaking indicate that the Korean screen has evolved in its shape, distinguishing it from screens used in other countries. In most other countries, the horizontal length parallel to the direction of the laced bamboo strips is longer than the vertical length in the direction of the string. But it is the other way around in Korean screens. This can be easily seen by comparing the lace line or string directions, which is sometimes referred to as a chain-line, of the Korean screen, as shown in Fig. 7 and the Chinese and Japanese screen, shown in Figs. 4-6. Another characteristic of the Korean screen can be found in the way of lacing bamboo strips up with string. In many cases of Korean screens found in recent years, as shown in Figs. 7 and 9, the bamboo strips in a screen are laced in a staggered direction from the middle of the screen. However, it can be seen that the screens used in Korea, China, and Japan in the 1930s, shown in Figs. 4, 5, 6, and 8 were tied straight, not staggered.

wood-51-6-509-g9
Fig. 9. Staggered arrangement of the chain line of Korean screen for papermaking.
Download Original Figure
3.3. Changes in manufacturing methods of traditional Hanji
3.3.1. Gadoomtteugi and Heulimtteugi

As described in the previous sections regarding Hanji-making molds, Gadoomtteugi is a papermaking technique where a mold with a deckle is employed to temporarily contain an aqueous fibrous mixture within a set of screen and deckle. The wet sheet of fibers forms as water strains through the screen. It can be seen that the Korean-type Gadoomtteugi mold shown in Fig. 8 and its operation methods existed until the 1930s. Currently, Japanese-type Gadoomtteugi mold and technique are being practiced in Korea, which was introduced to Korea around the period of Japanese occupation.

Even before the official Japanese occupation period, the Japanese Empire promoted a policy of disseminating the Japanese-type Gadoomtteugi technique in Korea, and the governmental industrial training center established in Seoul in 1907 was actively used for this purpose. At that time, Japan took effective control of Korea and established the “Department of Applied Chemistry” in the government industrial training center to teach Japanese-type Gadoomtteugi technique. Further, the graduates were sent across the country to disseminate the technique by conducting papermaking classes. These classes not only covered the papermaking process but also included instructions on how to cultivate Daknamu, providing valuable knowledge to local paper makers. The papermaking classes continued until the 1930s, after the government training center was promoted to “Gyeongseong Technical School” and renamed “Gyeongseong Technical High School,” and soon, the Japanese-type Gadoomtteugi method became commonplace all over the country. The main purpose of spreading the Japanese-type Gadoomtteugi method was to turn the Hanji-making industry into a production base for Japanese paper (Park, 2023).

In the paper manufacturing process using Gadoomtteugi, the worker either holds the mold steadily in a balanced position after scooping up the aqueous fibrous mixture or rocks the mold back and forth. In the former case, the bast fibers in the paper are arranged without a specific direction, and in the latter case, the bast fibers tend to be arranged in the front-back direction, which is the direction of the chain line. Most of the papers made using the Japanese-type Gadoomtteugi method fall under the latter category.

Heulimtteugi is a unique papermaking method practiced only in Korea, which eliminates the need for deckle sticks or a deckle. In this method, an aqueous mixture is not temporarily contained within the mold because of the absence of the deckle. The Heulimtteugi worker scoops an aqueous fibrous mixture from the vat with the mold from the front and tilts it in the opposite direction to let the mixture flow down. This technique is called “Apmuljil” in Korean. Subsequently, the mixture is scooped using the mold possessing previously mounted fibers from one of the sides and tilted to the opposite side, letting the mixture flow down. This technique is called “Yupmuljil” in Korean. Fibers on the screen are oriented in a back-and-forth direction by Apmuljil and side to side by Yupmuljil on top of the fibers in the direction of back and forth. This process when repeated results in paper with multiple layers of crossly bounced fibers.

The graph in Fig. 10 shows the results of measuring the tensile index in the laid direction and the chain line for the paper produced by Gadoomtteugi and Heulimtteugi techniques at the National Research Institute of Cultural Heritage. As shown in this graph, the tensile index of the paper made using the Gadoomtteugi shows a significantly higher value in the chain-line direction than in the laid direction. In contrast to that, the tensile index of the paper made using the Heulimtteugi is similar in both directions. Such paper has similar contraction-expansion rates or tensile strength in the horizontal and vertical directions, making it difficult to tear in either direction.

wood-51-6-509-g10
Fig. 10. Tensile index of paper manufactured by Heulimtteugi and Gadoomtteugi. Modified from Jeong et al. (2022) with permission of National Research Institute of Cultural Heritage.
Download Original Figure

Thus, paper characteristics are dependent upon the directions of the strands of bast fibers, which are arranged differently using different paper molds and manufacturing methods.

Currently, the only method that has been handed down as the Korean traditional Hanji-making method is Heulimtteugi.

3.3.1.1. Cross bar and cord for Heulimtteugi

In a common Heulimtteugi technique currently practiced in Korea, the far end of the supporting frame usually is tied to a cross bar installed above the center of the vat so that one person can handle the large mold (Fig. 11). Notably, there is no historical record indicating when Koreans began employing the crossbar and cord to secure the supporting frame in Heulimtteugi. However, tying one end of the mold to hang with a cord closely resembles the method used in the Japanese Gadoomtteugi technique.

wood-51-6-509-g11
Fig. 11. A Heulimtteugi scene using a mold hanging on the cross bar.
Download Original Figure

The practice of hanging one end of the mold can be attributed to a single person required to manage a large mold effectively, especially when crafting larger sheets of paper. It is inferred that such a Hanji-making method was not common in Korea until the early 1900s. One piece of evidence supporting this inference is the absence of a crossbar for hanging the frame in an old drawing depicting Hanji-making. This drawing appears on the cover page of the Hanji sample book titled “Paper of Gyeongsangbuk-do,” published in 1926. In addition, we do not observe a cross bar or tying support of a cord for a mold in any of the photos captured in the 1930s in Korea. As an additional clue, according to the contents of the “Government Industrial Training Center Report” published in 1909, small white papers (length 60 cm, width approx. 24–27 cm) were produced by one person, whereas large papers (length 75–78 cm, width approx. 51–54 cm) were produced by two persons. However, currently, the larger Hanji sheets (93 cm in length and 63 cm in width) than those produced by two persons as described above can be produced by one person using the Heulimtteugi mold, which is tied on a cord to be suspended.

Therefore, it can be seen that it was not common to suspend the Heulimtteugi mold on a cross bar to make Hanji in Korea in the 1930s.

In contrast, in Japan, the papermaking technique involving suspending a mold frame from a cord has been used since at least 1745 (Seki, 1965).

It was found that the Chinese were already using the papermaking technique of hanging a papermaking mold using a cord to make large pieces of paper. This technique was introduced to Japan in the 1700s, as evidenced by the book titled “Drawings of Paper Making and Paper Store of All Times (故今紙漉,紙屋圖絵).” The oldest drawing of papermaking using a hanging mold in Japan is found in the book. According to the accompanying description, this papermaking method using a hanging mold is of Chinese origin.

Based on the findings from the investigation, it is clear that the Japanese developed their own papermaking tools and methods by adapting the Chinese technique that uses a hanging mold operated by one person. That is the Japanese Gadoomtteugi method that was introduced to Korea in the early 1900s and has been generalized in Korea today.

No historical records indicate that the Heulimtteugi technique, involving the use of a hanging mold, was practiced in Korea prior to the introduction of the Japanese Gadoomtteugi method. Moreover, although there is some emotional evidence, there is no direct evidence that Koreans applied the Japanese technique of mold-hanging to the Korean Heulimtteugi. As a result, the origin of the cross bar and the cord for the Heulimtteugi method needs to be clarified to understand how the Korean traditional papermaking method, Heulimtteugi, developed.

Meanwhile, a Heulimtteugi technique that required two individuals to create a large piece of Hanji existed. In this technique, one person holds the handles tied at both ends of the mold and the other person grips the opposite end to operate the mold. Fig. 12 depicts a scene of papermaking using Heulimtteugi with two persons. This technique is not common anymore in the Korean Hanji-making field.

wood-51-6-509-g12
Fig. 12. Heulimtteugi technique carried by two persons.
Download Original Figure
3.3.2. Moknamutteugi

For preparing a large piece of Hanji without suspending a mold by one person, another Heulimtteugi technique called “Moknamutteugi” was carried in Korea. To perform this technique, two-thirds of a long cylindrical wood called “Moknamu” (Fig. 13) is immersed in a vat at an angle such that one-third of it is stuck out of the water and falls back on the frame of the vat. Subsequently, the papermaker places a papermaking mold on the stuck-out part of Moknamu horizontally while holding the opposite side of the mold. For papermaking, the papermaker then scoops and tosses the aqueous mixture using the mold balancing on Moknamu as shown in Fig. 14. This technique has been in use in some villages of Gyeongsang-do and Gangwon-do, but it has almost disappeared from the traditional Korean paper production site in Korea. Pictures are Moknamutteugi scene filmed by an American handmade-paper researcher Tim Barrett in Shinheung-Ri near Samcheok, Gangwon-do in 1977.

wood-51-6-509-g13
Fig. 13. Moknamu, a piece of cylindrical wood. Adapted from Choi (2015) with permission of National Intangible Heritage Center.
Download Original Figure
wood-51-6-509-g14
Fig. 14. Moknamutteugi scene in Shinheung-Ri near Samcheok, Korea in 1977. Unpublished photos of Barrett with permission.
Download Original Figure

For reference, Moknamu is a piece of cylindrical wood that is usually inserted between the two ropes of the tug-of-war, and is also called a “Binyeomok,” which is a Korean traditional hairpin, according to the Encyclopedia of Korean Folklore published by National Folk Museum of Korea.

3.4. Changes in drying methods

As shown in Fig. 3 wet fibers mounted on a primitive papermaking mold were dried in the sun. However, with the introduction of a separate screen in papermaking, the production of multiple sheets of paper became possible, leading to the adoption of various drying methods. There is a record in “Cheongonggaemul (天公開物)” published in 1637 during the reign of the Ming Dynasty stating that a wall was installed and heated to dry the wet paper attached to it (Hunter, 1932; Xing, 1991). It is presumed that there was a similar drying facility in Korea in the past.

Meanwhile, it was reported that a paper-drying facility in the form of a floor warming system “Ondol” was used in the early 1900s in Korea (Park, 2023). Nevertheless, in the cases of thick or large paper, they were dried under the sun by spreading them out on a grassy field at that time (Hunter, 1936; Park, 2023). Furthermore, around the 1920s, wooden panels and dryer facilities were introduced in Korea for drying paper (Park, 2023).

Even today, the drying method using wooden panels and the dryer is predominantly used for drying Hanji in Korea.

4. CONCLUSIONS

To unravel the evolution of traditional Hanji-making techniques up to the present day, we analyzed the Hanji manufacturing molds and manufacturing techniques dating back to ancient times.

Regarding the changes in the pretreatment technology in Hanji-making, natural materials were historically used for an extended period. However, as time passed, new materials or chemicals were introduced to improve work efficiency. Nevertheless, the fast and convenient modern methods can compromise the quality of Hanji. Consequently, traditional pretreatment methods are adhered to as much as possible to produce high-quality traditional Hanji.

Regarding changes in Hanji-making molds, this study revealed the existence of Korean traditional Gadoomtteuji molds and techniques, which are similar to those from the Chinese techniques. It was found that both Gadoomtteugi and Heulimtteugi molds were traditionally used in Korea. However, Korean traditional Gadoomtteuji faded out, and Japanese-style Gadoomtteugi techniques became common in Korea following the Japanese occupation period. Conversely, Heulimtteugi has emerged as the predominant traditional papermaking method in Korea, distinguished by its absence of a deckle frame or deckle sticks, even though the exact time of its inception remains uncertain. Heulimtteugi is a unique Hanji-making technology used only in Korea, and it continues to represent the traditional Hanji-making method to this day. Notably, unlike in other countries, the vertical length in the direction of the chain line is longer than the horizontal length in the laid direction on the papermaking screen.

The manufacturing method of Hanji has evolved in tandem with the changes in manufacturing molds. The Korean traditional Gadoomtteugi method, which involves one person making small paper and two people making large paper, transformed during the Japanese occupation period into the Japanese-style Gadoomtteugi, where mold is suspended from a cord, allowing a single person to operate the mold. In addition, it was discovered that to make a large piece of Hanji involving one person in the Heulimtteugi method, a technique of hanging a mold on a cord and a cross bar became prevalent. However, the Moknamutteugi technique, once used in many regions of Korea, has since disappeared. Furthermore, the Heulimtteugi technique conducted by two persons is no longer a common practice in Korea.

For the first time, this study introduces the high likelihood of the adoption of the mold-hanging technique into the Heulimtteugi method from techniques developed in foreign countries. However, it is important to note that further evidence is required to fully substantiate this claim.

In summary, this study finds that the raw materials, molds, and techniques used in Hanji-making remained relatively consistent from ancient times to the Joseon Dynasty. However, there have been significant changes during the Japanese occupation period, including the disappearance of the traditional Gadoomtteugi method, the changes in raw materials, names, and size, and the possible influence of the mold hanging in Heulimtteugi. Currently, some traditional names of Hanji have been reintroduced, Daknamu bast fiber remains the main raw material of the traditional Hanji, and Heulimtteugi is treated as the traditional Hanji-making method.

CONFLICT of INTEREST

No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

This research was supported by a Research Project (FP0802-2023-02-2023) through the National Institute of Forest Science (NiFoS), Korea.

REFERENCES

1.

Ahn, J.Y., Bae, S.B. 2018. Investigation of paper characteristics on old documents related to the head family of admiral Yi Sun-sin. Journal of Conservation Science 34(5): 407-420.

2.

Bethell, E.T. 1908. Exportation of Hanji. Daehan Maeil Shinbo, October 3.

3.

Cho, J.H., Kim, K.J., Park, S.B., Eom, T.J. 2009. Comparison of the functional properties of Hanji depending on the different manufacturing process. Journal of Korea TAPPI 41(3): 46-48.

4.

Choi, M.S. 2015. Juldarigi, tugging excitement: Special exhibitions and commemorative events for the registration to UNESCO intangible cultural heritage of humanity. https://www.iha.go.kr/service/search_all_item_view.nihc

5.

Choi, T.H., Cho, N.S. 1996. New Korean traditional papermaking from paper mulberry (I): Pulping characteristics of Broussonetia kazinoki Siebold. Journal of Korea TAPPI 28(1): 49-59.

6.

Chung, Y.K. 1996. A study on the color of colored paper of Joseon Dynasty. M.S. Thesis, Konkuk University, Korea.

7.

Han, Y., Lee, S.M. 2021a. Investigation on the awareness and preference for wood culture to promote the value of wood: I. Awareness of wood and cultural experience. Journal of the Korean Wood Science and Technology 49(6): 616-642.

8.

Han, Y., Lee, S.M. 2021b. Investigation on the awareness and preference for wood to promote the value of wood: II. Awareness of wood cultural resources. Journal of the Korean Wood Science and Technology 49(6): 643-657.

9.

Han, Y., Lee, S.M., Choi, J., Park, C.Y. 2021. A study on classification of wood cultural resources in South Korea. Journal of the Korean Wood Science and Technology 49(5): 430-452.

10.

Han, Y., Yang, M.S., Lee, S.M. 2022. Investigation on the awareness and preference for wood culture to promote the values of wood: III. Living environment and trend of wood utilization. Journal of the Korean Wood Science and Technology 50(6): 375-391.

11.

Hunter, D. 1932. Old Papermaking in China and Japan. Mountain House Press, Chillicothe, OH, USA.

12.

Hunter, D. 1936. A Papermaking Pilgrimage to Japan, Korea and China. Pyson Printers, New York, NY, USA.

13.

Hyun, K.S., Kim, M.J., Lee, M.K. 2005. Printability improvement of Hanji. Journal of Korea TAPPI 37(4): 52-59.

14.

Ichiro, T. 1918. Suggestion on Improvement of Joseonji. Maeil Shinbo, December 25. p. 4.

15.

Jeon, C., Jin, Y.M. 2000. Studies on the dyeing of Hanji by natural dye-stuffs (I): With a focus on the color tone of yellow color series. Journal of Korea TAPPI 32(3): 48-56.

16.

Jeon, Y.J. 2011. A study on the changes of area of paper mulberry and paper, and temple paper-manufacture seen in Gwanchan Jiriji (geography of eight provinces edited by government) in the early Joseon Dynasty. Journal of Local History and Culture 14(1): 47-77.

17.

Jeong, H.Y., Choi, K.H., Lee, K.S., Jo, B.M. 2012. Studies on conservation of the beeswax-treated annals of Joseon Dynasty. Journal of Korea TAPPI 44(6): 70-78.

18.

Jeong, M.J., Bogolitsyna, A., Jo, B.M., Kang, K.Y., Rosenau, T., Potthast, A. 2014a. Deterioration of ancient Korean paper (Hanji), treated with beeswax: A mechanistic study. Carbohydrate Polymers 101: 1249-1254.

19.

Jeong, M.J., Kang, K.Y., Markus, B., Kim, H.J., Jo, B.M., Potthast, A. 2014b. Deterioration of ancient cellulose paper, Hanji: Evaluation of paper permanence. Cellulose 21: 4621-4632.

20.

Jeong, S.W., Son, H.N., Jang, K.J., Jeong, S.Y. 2022. Korean Paper, Hanji. In: Analysis, Ed. by Park, J.S., Jeong, S.W., Kim, M.N., Kim, J.W., Son, H., Jang, K.J., and Jung, S.Y. National Research Institute of Cultural Heritage, Daejeon, Korea.

21.

Jo, H.J. 1995. A study on a few uses of paper mulberry bark fiber. M.S. Thesis, Konkuk University, Korea.

22.

Kang, Y.S., Yang, E.J. 2012. Characteristics of beeswax-treated Hanji aged by closed and ventilated chamber. Journal of Korea TAPPI 44(6): 9-14.

23.

Kim, J.B. 2015a. Article No. 1 of the veritable records of King Sejo on Dec. 12, 1457 in Joseon Dynasty. https://sillok.history.go.kr/id/kga_10312012_001

24.

Kim, J.B. 2015b. Article No. 2 of the veritable records of King Seongjong on Dec. 28, 1473 in Joseon Dynasty. https://sillok.history.go.kr/id/kia_10412028_002

25.

Kim, S.K. 2002. A study on the tax system of paper in the early Joseon Dynasty. The Journal of Korean Historical-folklife 15: 77-104.

26.

Lee, H.W., Park, J.H., Hwang, C.W., Lee, O.K. 2021a. Analysis of whole bark and inner bark contents of mulberry trees from 43 regions. In: Kim, J.S. (ed), Online Conference, Proceeding of the Korean Society of Wood Science and Technology Spring Meeting, p. 93.

27.

Lee, H.W., Park, J.H., Hwang, C.W., Lee, O.K. 2021b. Characteristic analysis of mucilage from Abelmoschus manihot. In: Kim, J.S. (ed), Online Conference, Proceeding of the Korean Society of Wood Science and Technology Spring Meeting, p. 93.

28.

Lee, K.R. 1958. The paper-manufacturing in the early Joseon Dynasty. Yoksa Hakbo 10: 1-38.

29.

Lee, K.R. 1962. Paper manufacture in buddhist temples during in the late Joseon Dynasty. The Korean Historical Review 17·18: 201-219.

30.

Lee, O.K., Lee, K.T., Lee, H.W., Rho, J.G., Jo, H.J., Nam, K.H. 2021c. A Story of Forgotten Hanji. National Institute of Forest Science, Seoul, Korea.

31.

Lee, S.H., Yoo, S.I., Choi, T.H. 2015. Development of natural dyed Korean traditional paper for cultural properties conservation and storage (Part 1): Antifungal, insect repellent activities and stability on metals. Journal of Korea TAPPI 48(3): 80-90.

32.

Lee, S.H., Yoo, S.I., Choi, T.H. 2016. Development of natural dyed Korean traditional paper for cultural properties conservation and storage (Part 2): Antifungal, insect repellent activities and stability on metals. Journal of Korea TAPPI 48(3): 80-90.

33.

Lucilla, N. 2021. Presentation of ‘La carta tradizionale Hanji e la sua applicazione nel restrauro’. In: Jeonju, Korea, Proceedings of International Symposium on Jeonju Hanji.

34.

Park, G. 2019. Change in traditional papermaking technology through ‘Papermaking Institute’ during the period of Japanese occupation. Intangible Heritage Studies 4(1): 77-112.

35.

Park, G. 2023. A study on the technology and policy of papermaking in modern and contemporary Korea. Ph.D. Thesis, Korea National University of Cultural Heritage, Korea.

36.

Park, H.S. 2012. Sigwon (試券) in the late of Joseon: Around the answer sheet on exam type. Gomunseo Yeongu 41: 161-196.

37.

Park, J.H. 2017. Raw materials of paper and the production of mixed papers in the early Joseon Dynasty. Dongyanghak 66: 113-132.

38.

Park, J.K. 2011. The production of paper and “So (所) Production System” of Goryeo Dynasty (918-1392. AD). Korean Studies 35: 49-74.

39.

Park. J.W. 2010. The forms and features of Hongpae in Koryo Dynasty. Gomunseo Yeongu 37: 1-33.

40.

Park, M.O., Yoon, S.L. 2009. Properties of natural dyeing of bast fiber (Part 1): Properties of dye and extraction condition of sappan wood, gardenia and gallnut. Journal of Korea TAPPI 41(3): 49-59.

41.

Park, M.O., Yoon, S.L. 2010. Properties of natural dyeing of bast fiber (Part 2): Pre mordanting dyeing of sappan wood, gardenia and gallnut. Journal of Korea TAPPI 42(4): 1-14.

42.

Park, M.O., Yoon, S.L. 2011. Properties of natural dyeing of bast fiber (Part 3): Combination dyeing of gallnut-sappan wood and gardenia. Journal of Korea TAPPI 43(1): 1-10.

43.

Park, S.C., Choi, M.S., Lim, H.A. 2009. Aging characteristics of marketing Korean paper (Hanji). Journal of Conservation Science 25(2): 161-169.

44.

Poggi, N. 2016. Conservation of the globe papa giovanni XXIII. In: Kim, S.G., Ahn, J.Y., Lee, K.M., Shin, H.Y., and Son, M.K. (eds), Daejeon, Korea, Proceedings of the International Symposium on Hanji in Italy and Korea, pp. 79-104.

45.

Roh, J., Jo, H.J. 2022. Dyeing and color fastness properties of natural dyed actual size Hanji. Journal of the Korean Wood Science and Technology 50(1): 31-45.

46.

Roh, J., Jo, H.J., Lee, H.W., Lee, O.K., Nam, K.H. 2022a. The conservation of Hanji manufacturing method. I. Considerations for conservation of Gamji. In: Oh, J.G. (ed), Daegu, Korea, Proceeding of the Korean Society of Wood Science and Technology Spring Meeting, p. 23.

47.

Roh, J., Ju, S.G., Jo, H.J., Lee, H.W., Lee, O.K. 2022b. The conservation of Hanji manufacturing method. II. Dyeing properties of Hanji by Persicaria tinctoria (Aiton) Spach. In: Oh, J.G. (ed), Daegu, Korea, Proceeding of the Korean Society of Wood Science and Technology Spring Meeting, p. 36.

48.

Roh, J., Ju, S.G., Jo, H.J., Lee, H.W., Lee, O.K., Lee, G.Y. 2023. The conservation of Hanji manufacturing method. III. Manufacturing and color characteristics of Gamji by Persicaria tinctoria (Aiton) Spach dyeing of actual size Hanji. In: Oh, J.G. (ed), Jeonju, Korea, Proceeding of the Korean Society of Wood Science and Technology Spring Meeting, p. 29.

49.

Roh, J., Ju, S.G., Jo, H.J., Lee, O.K. 2021a. The conservation of Hanji manufacturing method. II. The manufacturing of Siji (papers for the civil examination). In: Kim, J.S. (ed), Gyeongju, Korea, Proceeding of the Korean Society of Wood Science and Technology Fall Meeting, p. 17.

50.

Roh, J., Ju, S.G., Jo, H.J., Lee, O.K., Kim, H.J. 2021b. The conservation of Hanji manufacturing method. III. The performance of Siji depending on manufacturing method. In: Kim, J.S. (ed), Gyeongju, Korea, Proceeding of the Korean Society of Wood Science and Technology Fall Meeting, p. 74.

51.

Roh, J., Ju, S.G., Jo, H.J., Lee, O.K., Nam, K.H. 2021c. The conservation of Hanji manufacturing method. III. The manufacturing and performance of Taeji. In: Kim, J.S. (ed), Online Conference, Proceeding of the Korean Society of Wood Science and Technology Spring Meeting, p. 33.

52.

Roh, J., Ju, S.G., Jo, H.J., Lee, O.K., Nam, K.H. 2021d. The conservation of Hanji manufacturing method. I. Considerations for conservation of Siji (papers for the civil examination). In: Kim, J.S. (ed), Online Conference, Proceeding of the Korean Society of Wood Science and Technology Spring Meeting, p. 91.

53.

Seki, Y. 1965. Papers of All Times, Drawings of Papermaking Places. Chioda Insach Kbushisakaisha, Tokyo, Japan.

54.

Seo, Y.B., Cho, C., Jeon, Y. 2001. Effect of traditional Hanji manufacturing process on its physical properties. Journal of Korea TAPPI 33(4): 28-34.

55.

Son, K.Y. 2003. A study on the ornamental notepapers: Focusing on papers of bamboo tablet pattern. Gomunseo Yeongu 23: 95-120.

56.

Son, K.Y. 2005. An analysis of papers used in historical manuscripts. Journal of Korean Society of Archives and Records Management 5(1): 79-105.

57.

Son, K.Y. 2007. Four types of the ornamental notepapers in the Joseon Dynasty. Journal of Studies in Bibliography 36: 297-320.

58.

Son, K.Y. 2017. Paper usage and supply of a literati household in seventeenth-century Joseon: Focusing on the diaries of Jo Geuksun. Korean Journal of Jangseogak Royal Library 38: 56-89.

59.

Song, K.J. 2008. The production and export of Korean paper under the Japanese imperialism. The Journal of Korean History 142: 337-366.

60.

Song, S. 2016. A temple paper crafts and its operating for the Goryeo Dynasty. Seokdang NonChong 65: 151-182.

61.

Xing, P.J. 1991. History of the Chinese Paper. Gwangil Munwhasa, Seoul, Korea. pp. 184-185.

62.

Yoo, S.I., Oh, S.K., Lee, S.H., Choi, T.H. 2009. Dyeing of Hanji with flowers of pagoda tree (Sophora japonica). Journal of Korea TAPPI 41(2): 34-39.

63.

Yoon, S.L. 2015. Microscopic observation of surface and cross section of Korean traditional paper-Hanji. Journal of Korea TAPPI 47(6): 49-56.

64.

Yoon, S.L., Jo, H.J., Park, S.B., Kim, H.J., Kim, J.K., Kim, S.I. 1996. Studies on wallpaper making using Hanji (I): Making and properties of Hanji for wallpaper. Journal of the Korean Wood Science and Technology 24(4): 15-21.

65.

Yoon, S.L., Jo, H.J., Park, S.B., Kim, J.K., Kim, S.I., Kim, H.J., Lee, M.H. 1997. A studies on wallpaper making using Hanji (II): Making and properties of Hanji wallpaper. Journal of the Korean Wood Science and Technology 25(4): 17-21.

66.

Yoon, S.L., Kim, H.J. 2002. Manufacturing of color Hanji using bast fibers stained dyed by two reactive dyes. Journal of Korea TAPPI 34(4): 44-50.

67.

Yoon, S.L, Ra, J.B. 2013. Orientation properties of Korean traditional paper-Hanji. Journal of Korea TAPPI 45(3): 52-58.