Table 4. The 1st and 2nd slip modulus of nail joint, and RMSE between predicted shear load in bi-linear curve and measured shear load

Type Method Slip modulus (kN/mm) RMSE (kN)
1st 2nd
M(G)S(L) A1) 0.558 0.037 0.198
B2) 0.618 0.033 0.168
C3) 0.619 0.034 0.170
D4) 0.595 0.040 0.230
E5) 0.569 0.039 0.218
M(G)S(T) A 0.554 0.037 0.207
B 0.611 0.031 0.151
C 0.613 0.032 0.161
D 0.595 0.040 0.237
E 0.567 0.039 0.221
M(P)S(L) A 0.595 0.063 0.139
B 0.671 0.056 0.106
C 0.672 0.057 0.109
D 0.641 0.068 0.165
E 0.612 0.065 0.153
M(P)S(T) A 0.509 0.060 0.112
B 0.573 0.055 0.084
C 0.574 0.055 0.085
D 0.557 0.067 0.148
E 0.533 0.065 0.137
Data from Karacabeyli and Ceccotti (1998).
Data from European Committee for Standardization (2005).
Data from Yasumura and Kawai (1997).
Data from CSIRO (1996).
Data from American Forest and Paper Association (2015).
RMSE: root-mean-squared error.